If you're new to investing, you've probably heard the terms “index fund” and “mutual fund” tossed around—though what exactly they are and which one is right for you may not be so clear. This article will walk you through key similarities and differences to help steer you toward the best option so you can make a confident and informed decision.

Funds vs individual stocks

Both mutual funds and index funds are investment vehicles that pool money from many investors to buy a diversified portfolio of assets (e.g., stocks or bonds). In other words, you purchase shares in a fund that spreads your money across many holdings (rather than choosing an individual investment).

You can either invest $100 in a singular stock, for example, or otherwise invest that same $100 in a fund containing 100 different stocks. Why spread your money out? Because diversification is one of the best ways out there to limit investment risk, embodying the adage “Don’t put all your eggs in one basket.” If one stock (or even several) performs poorly in this case, your portfolio is far less impacted than it would be had you invested in individual stocks. Both mutual funds and index funds ultimately pool money, providing instant diversification compared to individual stocks—but do so in different ways.

What are mutual funds?

A mutual fund is a pool of money collected from many investors that’s actively managed by a professional fund manager who selects investments based on the strategy of their fund. While one mutual fund might focus on large U.S. companies, for example, another might target international bonds or emerging markets.

Mutual funds are typically “actively managed,” meaning managers try to outperform the market by choosing investments they believe will do better than average. While this approach has the potential for higher returns, it also often comes with higher fees and less predictable performance.

What are index funds?

Making it that much more difficult for investors still learning finance terminology, an index fund is technically a specific type of mutual fund—though people typically talk about them as if they’re two different things, similar to how a square is a type of rectangle but not all rectangles are squares. Their different objectives likely feed into this distinction; while mutual fund managers strive for outperformance, index funds aim to mirror the performance of a specific market index (e.g., the S&P 500, including 500 of the largest companies in the U.S). In other words, index funds simply try to match the market rather than beat it.

Mutual funds vs. index funds: key differences

While both index funds and mutual funds allow you to invest in a variety of assets via a single fund and offer built-in diversification, important differences between them can significantly impact your investing experience, returns, and costs. These include…

Active vs. passive management

Management style differences (active management for mutual funds vs, passive management for index funds) directly impact costs, as the former style requires more time, research, and resources and is thus associated with higher fees known as “expense ratios.” These fees, in turn, can add up—especially over long investment horizons—and even a small difference in percentage can have big-time impacts on your total return. Index funds, meanwhile, are generally cheaper to own as they don’t require the same level of oversight or trading activity.

Performance expectations

Another major distinction is with respect to performance expectations. Mutual funds have a chance to beat the market, though never guaranteed, as a skilled fund manager can make great calls that produce above-average returns. They can also underperform the market, however, especially once fees are factored in. Index funds take a different approach, trying to match rather than beat the market; while you might miss out on the chance for outsized gains, you likewise avoid the risk of underperformance caused by poor management decisions.

Risk profile

Risk profile is also worth considering. Mutual funds vary widely in strategy; some are conservative and others aggressive, thus resulting in more volatile performance. Because they’re actively managed, an added layer of human decision-making can either mitigate or amplify risk. Index funds meanwhile, by design, are typically well-diversified and consistent with the market they track. This broad exposure helps reduce risk in many cases but also fully exposes investors to any market downturns.

Tax efficiencies

Finally, there’s the matter of tax efficiency. As mutual fund managers frequently buy and sell holdings in an attempt to optimize performance, such trades can generate capital gains that may be taxable when distributed to shareholders even if you personally didn’t sell any of your shares. Index funds, in contrast, tend to have lower turnover—meaning there’s less buying and selling inside the fund as part of a passive structure, resulting in fewer taxable events. This makes index funds generally more tax-efficient.

In short, index and mutual funds differ in how they're managed, how much they cost, how they perform, and how tax-friendly they are.

**Mutual fund vs index fund: Which is right for you?**

As with many other investment vehicles, neither a mutual fund nor index fund is inherently better or worse. The “right” option instead depends on specific investor needs, the following just a few factors to consider…

Your performance objective

Index funds are a solid option for long-term investors seeking steady, market-matching performance without the stress of constant monitoring or decision-making. They also have limitations, however, such as an inability to outperform the market as they’re instead designed to mirror it.

Hoping to beat the market and generate above-average returns? Look elsewhere. You also won’t have much control over specific holdings in your index fund portfolio as you’re investing in a pre-established list of companies; some investors find this lack of customization frustrating, especially if they want to focus on specific sectors or avoid companies that don’t align with their values.

Your risk tolerance

When it comes to investing, risk tolerance means how much market volatility (ups and downs) you feel comfortable with. This isn’t as simple as whether you’re open to risk or would rather play it safe (though that does come into play) but is more about specific metrics such as how long you plan to invest your money; the longer you plan to have funds invested, the more time they’ll have to back bounce following any dips in the market.

Index funds are designed to track the market, so when the market falls, so too does the fund in the absence of a built-in defense. Active mutual funds, on the other hand, have the ability to adjust their holdings in response to changing conditions; a manager might shift to more defensive stocks, hold more cash, or avoid certain assets altogether in an effort to minimize losses, such flexibility offering a layer of protection when markets turn volatile. As one example, bond mutual funds can steer clear of riskier bonds during periods of economic stress to potentially reduce downside risk.

Your desire for a more specialized portfolio

Index funds lack flexibility as they’re tied to a fixed list of holdings, meaning they’ll likely fall short if you're interested in targeting specific sectors (e.g., renewable energy or emerging markets) or avoiding companies that conflict with your values. You can't pick and choose which stocks the fund includes, after all, as it simply mirrors the index.

Mutual funds, in contrast, offer more flexibility and professional oversight: actively managed funds giving managers the freedom to select investments based on research, market conditions, or specific strategies. This is often advantageous if your investment goals are more specialized or niche. For example, a targeted mutual fund may align better with your goals than a broad index fund if you’re seeking exposure to a narrow industry.

The takeaway: mutual funds vs. index funds

Both index funds and mutual funds provide a simple way to build a diversified portfolio for those lacking the experience, time, or interest in choosing individual stocks or attempting to time the market—but each cater to diverse styles and preferences. While mutual funds provide active management and the possibility of higher returns (at a loftier cost and with more risk), index funds offer the appeal of low fees, broad exposure, and more reliable, market-based returns.

As you set off on your investing journey, don’t worry about choosing the perfect fund. What matters most is getting started, staying consistent, and learning on a continual basis. For more information, reach out to a professional financial advisor who can provide personalized advice.

Still have questions about investing? Schedule a FREE discovery call with one of our CFP® professionals to get them answered.

Featured

Jul 7, 2025

How to Invest in Stocks: A Guide for Beginners